The groundbreaking on the old Boston Store lot was set for 10 a.m. on October 10, and the time was chosen on purpose. Visit Brookfield explained in its newsletter that city officials and Visit Brookfield broke ground on the Brookfield Conference Center at 10 a.m. on October 10, 2018. Eight years later, they used the same date and hour to start the Brookfield Public Market, and they hope "10/10 at 10" becomes a tradition for future projects.
The date shows what the City of Brookfield is trying to do at the mall. One end of Brookfield Square has already been rebuilt around things to do other than shopping, and the city now wants to repeat that on the other end. This holiday season, the reworked parts of the mall are the ones with things on the calendar, and the empty lot off Moorland Road is fenced off for construction.
The end of the mall that already got its second act
Brookfield Mayor Steve Ponto said it directly at the October groundbreaking. As WISN reported, he credited the convention center with renewing energy on the south side of the mall, and he hopes the public market will do the same for the north side.
On the mall's former Sears side, the department store is gone. In its place, mall owner CBL Properties lists Movie Tavern by Marcus, WhirlyBall, OrangeTheory Fitness and Club Champion. Those businesses are for watching a movie, playing a game, working out or getting fitted for golf clubs. Movie Tavern Brookfield has been selling advance tickets for November showings.
CBL's description of Brookfield Square also lists a restaurant lineup of Cooper's Hawk, Uncle Julio's, Bravo, Bar Louie, Wasabi, Red Robin, Fleming's and Lou Malnati's. The mall's own directory lists Chick-fil-A, Naf Naf and Outback as well.
The convention-center side keeps adding places to eat. The Sheraton Milwaukee Brookfield Hotel is at 375 S. Moorland Road. Bloom Restaurant & Cafe, a brunch spot, is being built next door on surplus Sheraton parking at 315 S. Moorland Road. In September the Milwaukee Business Journal reported that it was aiming to open in November.
What is going up on the Boston Store lot
The Brookfield Public Market is meant to bring the same kind of reason to visit to the north end of the mall. The Freeman described it as a two-story building of about 54,000 square feet on a 1.3-acre lot that Irgens split off so it could be sold to Visit Brookfield. Visit Brookfield CEO Nancy Justman told the paper what is planned inside:
"We are looking at hot food vendors, some grocery style vendors, some Wisconsin handmade vendors, we do have meeting space upstairs, two bars, outdoor space."
The project is a partnership between the city, Visit Brookfield and Irgens Development. The city is a funding partner, and Visit Brookfield will own and run the market. Justman told The Freeman that the project will be paid for through a tax incremental financing district. According to WISN, organizers toured more than 45 markets around the country, including the Milwaukee Public Market, and Visit Brookfield expects about one million visitors a year.
People who live nearby can already get involved in a few ways:
- Main & Main. Visit Brookfield is planning a shop inside the market that sells only Wisconsin-made products. It has asked artists, woodworkers, potters, jewelry makers and specialty food producers from around the state to submit their work. Questions go to Dustin Hicks at Visit Brookfield.
- Programming survey. Visit Brookfield is running a short survey on the events people want at the market, such as live music, cooking classes, trivia nights and seasonal celebrations.
- The parcel next door. Dan Ertl, Brookfield's Director of Community Development, told The Freeman that the land around the market is planned for an "experiential retailer," meaning a store built around experiences more than shopping alone.
Justman told The Freeman that construction should take about a year and that the market should open in late fall 2027. WISN's report from the groundbreaking said spring 2028. Either way, the market will be open by the 2028 holiday season at the latest, and the site will be under construction for all of this one.
The larger decision the Council started on October 6
Four days before the groundbreaking, the city took a much bigger step. A press release from the mayor says the Common Council approved an agreement on Tuesday, October 6. The agreement gives the City of Brookfield the right to buy part of Brookfield Square, but does not require it to. During the review period, the city will study the property and work with possible development partners to decide whether a redevelopment plan can work. Paying for any purchase would need another vote by the Council.
TMJ4 reported that the price is $28 million and that the area covered runs from JCPenney to the movie theater, leaving out a small area near the theater. The station said the review period lasts 60 days. According to the same report, JCPenney, Express and Bath & Body Works are inside the area covered by the agreement. Merle Norman, which sits next to the movie theater, is outside it.
Merle Norman owner Erin Bubolz told TMJ4 that her store has been at Brookfield Square since the 1980s and that she believes it is the mall's longest local tenant. She heard about the agreement by text and email from the mall. "I'm very excited," she told the station. "I was kind of thinking it is about time." Brookfield Square opened in 1967.
The city has not said what would happen to the rest of the mall or its tenants if a redevelopment involved tearing down any part of the building. TMJ4 reported that the city would not answer that until the review period ends. Questions about development go to Dan Ertl at the City of Brookfield.
The season, date by date
The holiday events below are at the mall, the conference center, the Sheraton and two nearby tree lightings. The construction lot has nothing scheduled.
- Friday, Nov. 13: Santa photos start at Brookfield Square and run through Dec. 24. Hours vary by week, and the hours change again for Dec. 18 through Dec. 24.
- Nov. 14–15: The Milwaukee Fall Craft & Vendor Market is at the mall.
- Mondays, Nov. 16 through Dec. 14: Pet Photos with Santa sessions run at Santa's Workshop.
- Saturday, Nov. 21: Across Bluemound Road, The Corners of Brookfield holds its Holiday Tree Lighting from 4 to 6 p.m., with Santa, family activities and a drone show.
- Friday, Nov. 27: The day after Thanksgiving, the Perfectly Imperfect 4 You Craft Fair runs from 9 a.m. to 3 p.m. at the Brookfield Conference Center.
- Thursday, Dec. 3: The Village of Brookfield holds its tree lighting with Santa, horse-and-carriage rides, a petting farm and a 5:30 p.m. countdown.
- Dec. 12–13: The Milwaukee Winter Wonderland Craft & Vendor Market comes to Brookfield Square.
- Thursday, Dec. 31: The Sheraton Milwaukee Brookfield Hotel hosts a New Year's Eve party.
Every event on that list is at the mall's reworked side, the conference center, the hotel or a nearby venue. Next year's list could add the Public Market. Its building on the former Boston Store lot is under construction, and its Wisconsin maker shop is still accepting submissions.
Rebecca keeps up with projects like this one because they change what a part of town looks like long before anyone sells a house over them. If you have a question about what is changing near Brookfield Square, or want to talk about how it fits your own plans, Premier Choice Realty is glad to help. Let's Connect.